The recent wave of creators publicly posting eye-popping OnlyFans earnings may be hitting a credibility wall as adult film star Breckie Hill publicly questioned the legitimacy of viral income screenshots, suggesting that some of the numbers circulating online are exaggerated—or outright false.
Hill addressed the issue directly on X (formerly Twitter) following renewed scrutiny around high-profile earnings posts.
“Why are we lying about how much we make?” she wrote. “Next fake statement I see I’m posting SS from OF CFO confirming that they’re fake,” she added, punctuating the post with a laughing emoji.
Her comment quickly gained traction, with fans urging her to follow through and provide proof. One user replied, “People are making life decisions based on these fake screenshots. The lying needs consequences.”
Hill’s remarks arrive amid ongoing debate sparked by Piper Rockelle, who launched her OnlyFans account on January 1, shortly after turning 18. Rockelle initially shared screenshots claiming she earned more than $1 million within her first hour on the platform, followed by a second post suggesting her first-day total exceeded $2 million.
The posts quickly went viral—but just as quickly drew skepticism. Users flagged inconsistencies in the screenshots, and Rockelle ultimately deleted the earnings posts.
Not all figures have been disputed, however. Australian creator Annie Knight previously shared verified details of her 2025 performance, stating she earned approximately $2.8 million on OnlyFans, with a top month reaching $600,000. Knight framed the disclosure as transparency rather than promotion, noting that consistent earnings reassure her that “what I’m doing is still working.”
That transparency recently came to light in another way when Knight’s fiancé, Henry Brayshaw, addressed criticism of her career. Responding to direct messages questioning his relationship, Brayshaw emphasized that Knight’s work is structured and supported. “It’s a very professional operation,” he said.