Jazz Chisholm Jr. is forcefully pushing back against online rumors that his fiancée Ahnalys Santiago previously had an OnlyFans account, using humor, trolling, and blunt responses to shut down speculation that erupted shortly after their Christmas Day engagement.
The New York Yankees infielder found himself at the center of viral chatter after a post announcing his engagement circulated on X (formerly Twitter).
In the replies, several users questioned his relationship, with one viral comment suggesting Chisholm had “wifed up an OF model.” Others echoed the claim, prompting a flurry of reactions.
Chisholm didn’t stay silent. In multiple posts, he directly denied the allegation, insisting his fiancée has never had an OnlyFans account.
“My fiancé has never done OnlyFans,” Chisholm wrote in one response. “But maybe your mom did check on her right quick.”
When another user doubled down on the criticism, Chisholm leaned into his trademark confidence, replying, “I know my fiancé a millionaire too tho get up with me.”
As the discourse grew louder, the 27-year-old made clear that the comments weren’t bothering him. In a longer post, Chisholm explained that online trolling comes with the territory and won’t distract him from his work or personal happiness.
“Y’all be making me feel like I’m not a normal person,” he wrote. “Even in my offseason I can’t have fun on this app… Words don’t affect me. I’ve been slandered from when I was broke. You think now that I’m up a little back and forth on this app can hurt me?”
The speculation arrived after Chisholm proposed to Santiago, his longtime girlfriend, during a trip to Finland. According to People, the proposal took place beneath the northern lights, with Chisholm dropping to one knee in the snow.
Santiago later shared emotional posts celebrating the moment, calling herself “DA WIFEEEEE” and joking that Chisholm had “tricked” her into traveling across the world for the surprise.
The engagement photos went viral, drawing congratulatory messages but also scrutiny. Despite the noise, the Yankees star appears unfazed as he heads into the offseason riding both personal and professional momentum.
After a historic 30-home run, 30-steal campaign in 2025 and with his future in New York still a topic of discussion, Chisholm seems focused on enjoying a milestone moment off the field.