The 50 Biggest NFL Playoff Fails

With the pigskin playoffs in full swing, we're counting down the most notable screw-ups in postseason history.

Not Available Lead
Complex Original

Image via Complex Original

NFL playoffs#EPICFAIL50 Biggest NFL Playoff Fails

4th and 26

OK, Packers' defense: All you need to do is stop the Eagles from gaining over one-quarter of the entire field and you're in the NFC Championship. The failure to cover Freddie Mitchell(!) here is unforgivable.

Antonio Cromartie Whiffs on Tackle

Pay close attention to #31 in blue on this play. What were you thinking, Antonio? Maybe that's why he's got more baby mamas than successful tackles. Zing!

Red Right 88

The Cleveland Browns chose to pass in sub-zero weather with a 30 mph wind. The result is a fail that cost them a shot at the title. Doo doo, Browns.

Fog Bowl

We'll call this fail on Mother Nature. Crazy thing is, Randall Cunningham still threw for 407 yards in all that fog. Shame RC never made it to the Super Bowl.

Sea of Hands

The dreaded #triplefail: Three Miami Dolphin defenders let a single Oakland Raider outmuscle them for the ball for this infamous game-winning TD.

Kurt's Head Is Clearly NOT on a Swivel

Kurt Warner was going to come back this season. He really was.

Aaron Rodgers Fumble vs. Cardinals

Aaron Rodgers makes losing look smooth to end this Wild Card game. But hey, wasn't that a face-mask?

Eugene Robinson and the Strippers

Bros before hoes. Apparently Eugene didn't get the memo, as he was caught with a Miami hooker the night before Super Bowl XXXIII. Guess who got burned by Rod Smith on the game-turning play?

Joe Montana, You Got Knocked Out!

Now that's a blindside hit!

Super Bowl XXIV: Lopsided

Did the Broncos get off the bus? You guys failed spiritually, mentally, emotionally, and physically.

Donovan Throws Up

This moment from Super Bowl XXXIX was the start of McNabb's ending. Where was Rex Grossman when you needed him?

Barret Robbins Goes AWOL

Barret Robbins decided it was a great idea to go on a two-day bender, in Tijuana, two days before Super Bowl XXXVII. Need we say more?

Gary Anderson Misses Field Goal

Was the fix in? Gary Anderson had not missed a field goal in two years until this one, which cost the Vikings a shot at the Super Bowl. Somebody check homie's phone records.

Kevin Dyson Tackled One Yard Short

Titans: "Let me put the head in?" Rams: "Hell no." And so goes history.

The Drive

A less cynical perspective on this moment might emphasize Elway's heroics over Cleveland's failure to stop him. But nope, this is Cleveland we're talking about, and we are absolute cynics. Sorry, Mistake by the Lake.

Peyton Manning's Four Picks

The 2003 AFC Championship is one that Peyton Manning would like to forget...but we certainly won't.

Kicking to Devin Hester

Any coach who decides to kick this guy the ball deserves everything he gets. This means you, Tony Dungy.

Where is Chad?

The above video is only the preview of what happened in the actual game, but suffice to say that Ochocinco got lost on Revis Island in back-to-back weeks. We ain't heard from Ocho since, to be honest.

TO Catch vs. Green Bay Packers

We count five Packers around the ball, but none with the wherewithal to knock it down. C'mon sons.

Hank Baskett Can't Recover Onside Kick

Kendra...your man's hands are suspect.

First-Ever Hail Mary

Great play by Staubach and Pearson, tremendous fail by the Vikings DB. Sidebar: How creepy is this archival footage? We kept waiting for a ref to get stabbed or something.

Tavaris Jackson Decleated

Tavaris had a chance, he blew it...and indirectly ensured that we'd have to deal with Favre for another two seasons.

Kurt Warner Pick to James Harrison

The worst possible way to end a half...this play was more worthy of a grocery-bagger than a future HOF-er. Sorry, Kurt.

Eddie George Bobble

Bobblehead Eddie butterfingers the ball and lets Ray Lewis put the final nail in the Titans coffin. Ray, if you're reading this: We don't mean it like that.

Bills Lose Four Straight Super Bowls

It used to be an annual occasion in the '90s...new year, new Bills fail.

Nick Harper Chased Down by Big Ben

This game-saving tackle in the AFC Divisional Playoff game led to Vanderjagt's terrible miss moments later, and a Steelers' victory. Word to drunk coeds, Big Ben's pursuit skills are legendary.

Marquez Pope Burned

We don't know if Marquez somehow LeBron'ed this clip off of YouTube, but the only evidence we have of slow-ass Shannon Sharpe burning Pope (#49) in the 2000 AFC Championship is this picture. As far as blown coverages go, that was a deep-throat gagger.

Bo Jackson's Injury

This was Bo's last play in the NFL. The real fail here is on us fans for missing out on more of his awesome runs.

Garo's Gaffe

It'd be an insult to womankind to say that Fins kicker Garo Yepremian throws like a girl. Luckily, the Dolphins won Super Bowl VII despite Garo's fail.

Immaculate Reception

Like some unfortunate young men, the Raiders learned this lesson the hard way: Bad things happen when you don't "wrap up" at the climax.

Peyton Manning Throws Pick to Saints

Peyton Manning "gives back" to his home city in last year's Super Bowl.

Tuck Rule

The fail that wasn't...but should've been. How history would've changed had this play been called the other way. No Gisele, no hair plugs, no UGGs endorsement.

Music City Miracle

C'mon, Buffalo. You had to know something like this was coming. Forward pass or not (and it wasn't), your special teams was not very special on this play.

John Kasay Kicks Ball Out of Bounds

Kickers, all you have to do is make your makeable field goals and kick your kickoffs straight. Is that too much to ask? Clearly, it is.

Cards DBs Not Covering Holmes

How many Cardinals does it take to let a WR catch a game-winning pass in the final minute of a Super Bowl? Three, apparently.

Rodney Harrison Can't Make the Play

Tyree gets all of the plaudits, and rightfully so, but we still can't figure out how Harrison couldn't break this play up. Conclusive proof that HGH doesn't work.

Brett Favre's Pick Against Giants

We could have made an entire supplemental list of Favre Funballs Gone Bad.

Neil O'Donnell Super Bowl Picks

We can't even call these ill-fated O'Donnell passes "wounded" ducks—there are more like quadraplegic ducks.

Tony Romo Botched Snap

Such a fail that it was immortalized in rhyme by Lil Wayne: "You suck like Tony Romo, no homo." Couldn't have said it better ourselves.

Giants Muffed Field Goal

Not only did the Giants give up a huge lead to the Niners, but this bad snap cost them the game—plus the horribly missed pass interference by the refs. When it fails, it pours.

Jake Delhomme's Five Picks

The musical selection for this video says it all. And in case you forgot, Jake Delhomme still sucks.

Jackie Smith's Dropped Pass

Like Bill Buckner, the name Jackie Smith conjures up one play, and one play only: this terrible fail in Super Bowl XIII.

Thurman Thomas Can't Find His Helmet

The Bills RB famously misplaced his helmet before Super XXVI, thus missing the first two Buffalo offensive plays. Thomas ended up playing terribly and surprise, surprise: The Bills got stomped by the Redskins. Not the first time a pro athlete would forget about his "hat" and suffer the consequences.

Vanderjagt Misses Field Goal

This 46-yard miss ended the Colts' 2005 season, and also permanently changed Vanderjagt's name to "Stupid Fucking Kicker."

Leon Lett's Fumble

Had Leon thought that the ball was a blunt or an eightball, he probably would have held on tighter. Sadly, the ball was leather and this is Leon's celebration fail seen 'round the world.

Houston Oilers Lose Lead

This is the worst breakdown in NFL postseason history, with the Oilers blowing a 35-point lead in the second half to Reich and the Bills. See, the Bills aren't always full of fail.

Brett Favre Throws Pick to Saints

Dude, all you had to do was NOT throw this pass and the Vikes could've made (and probably won) the Super Bowl. Way worse than the Favre Dong leaking as Brett's worst moment of 2010.

Earnest Byner: The Fumble

We felt bad for Earnest then, and we still feel bad for him now, but that was an inexcusable #lategamefail. Damn, Cleveland.

Asante Samuel Ruins Perfect Season

Maybe we should thank Asante for failing to grab this pick at the end of Super Bowl XLII. Had he made the catch, we'd have to live with the '08 Pats earning the "Best Team Ever" designation in the history books. That, and New England fans would be even more fucking annoying and insufferable. So, then: FAIL for Asante and New England, but a WIN for the rest of mankind. Thanks, guys!

Wide Right

Let's not forget that it was a 47-yarder—not really a gimme. But still, this is probably the most famous missed kick of all time. For that, Scott Norwood is definitely first-ballot Hall of Fail.

Stay ahead on Exclusives

Download the Complex App