Sports

Judge Dismisses Aaron Hernandez's 2015 Murder Conviction

A judge has officially dismissed the murder conviction Aaron Hernandez was handed during the Odin Lloyd trial.

Aaron Hernandez makes a court appearance in 2013.
Image via Getty/Boston Globe/Contributor
Getty

Just one day after Aaron Hernandezdied in April following a suspected suicide, a Boston Globe report emerged indicating that his family might be able to collect millions of dollars owed to him by the Patriots and the NFL as a result of his death. The belief was that, because Hernandez died before he was able to finish the appeal of his 2015 murder conviction in the Odin Lloyd trial, a legal principle known as "abatement ab initio" would apply to his case. It would give his lawyers the opportunity to vacate his conviction, which would essentially allow for him to die an innocent man and allow for his family to go after the money that the Patriots and NFL refused to pay him after he was found guilty of killing Lloyd.

On Tuesday morning, Hernandez’s court-appointed lawyer John Thompson appeared before a judge and argued that Hernandez’s conviction should be overturned due to his death. The prosecution in the case argued against Thompson as they said they would and said that the conviction should stand. But according to WBZ-TV reporter Christina Hager, the judge presiding over the hearing, Judge Susan Garsh, sided with Thompson and said that the law clearly states Hernandez’s conviction should be abated because of his death. She explained that, despite the circumstances surrounding Hernandez’s death, she had to stick to the letter of the law and throw out the conviction.

The prosecution in the case can file a appeal, and they are expected to do so. But it sounds like getting a judge to overturn Judge Garsh’s decision is going to be a long shot.

Hernandez seemed to suggest that he knew his complicated legal situation would play out this way when he wrote, "You’re rich," in a suicide note addressed to his fiancée Shayanna Jenkins-Hernandez.

Related Stories

Aaron Hernandez listens during his double murder trial.
sports

Aaron Hernandez’s Legal Troubles Won’t End With His Death, Expert Explains

Aaron Hernandez's death leaves multiple legal loose ends. But the ruling of suicide and potential of CTE could possibly benefit his estate and victims.

Jessica Meiselman3298 days ago
Aaron Hernandez listens to lawyers make arguments during his double murder trial.
sports

Aaron Hernandez's Family Could End Up Making Millions of Dollars as a Result of His Death

The Patriots and the NFL could be forced to pay Aaron Hernandez millions of dollars due to his death.

Chris Yuscavage3302 days ago
Aaron Hernandez arrives at a court hearing in 2013.
sports

Prosecutors Fighting to Prevent Aaron Hernandez's Murder Conviction From Being Dismissed

The prosecutors in Aaron Hernandez's murder trial are not going to just sit back and let his lawyers get his conviction overturned.

Chris Yuscavage3291 days ago

Stay ahead on Exclusives

Download the Complex App